<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<itemContainer xmlns="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xsi:schemaLocation="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5 http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5/omeka-xml-5-0.xsd" uri="https://www.abyayalanews.org/items/browse?tags=Intellectual+Property+Rights&amp;sort_field=Dublin+Core%2CTitle&amp;output=omeka-xml" accessDate="2026-11-12T06:03:04-08:00">
  <miscellaneousContainer>
    <pagination>
      <pageNumber>1</pageNumber>
      <perPage>12</perPage>
      <totalResults>8</totalResults>
    </pagination>
  </miscellaneousContainer>
  <item itemId="1688" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="693">
        <src>https://www.abyayalanews.org/files/original/f547c36664a2b81bb6b206fb3fd68a7e.pdf</src>
        <authentication>09f95fdb565f48d7915b6b9556de2d5a</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="6">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="324">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="30027">
                    <text>PERSPECTIVES ON BIODIVERSI TY AND I NTELLECTUAL PROPERTY

Amazonian Peoples on Biodiversity and ·tPR
Resolutions from the Coordinating Body of Indigenous Communities
of the Amazon Basin's Regional Meeting
September. 1994, Santo Cruz de Io Sierra. Bo/Mo
he Coordinating Body of
Indigenous Peoples of the
Amazon Basin, repre.seming
Indigenous c01nmunities in this region,

T

which is one of the richest in biodivcrsi

4

ty in the world. will not be excluded
from m:aking itS voice hc~trd in respect to
this subject.
In this regard. the Indigenous com·
munities are well aware of the impor·

t..'lnce of protecting biodiversity, as well
as our knowledge related to it. \Ve know
that our 3utonomy and assurance of life
with dignity ,,,.m deJ&gt;end on the process·
es of comro l. consen•ation and develop·

mcm of these resources especially over
the next few ye.'\rs. when the world will
be discussing the issues of biodiversity.
\ Vc must be quite dear that we, 1he
Indigenous communities. are the ones
entitled to claim proprietary rights to
tht..se resources. in spite of increasing
claims made by multinational corpora·
tions of the Non.h.
This situation obliges indigenous
people and our organizations to take
positions and elaborate strategies rclc·
vam to current and future generations.
With thJs in mind. COlO \. under the
auspices of the UN Dc\'clopmem
Program. organized a regional meeting
in South America. The conclusions and
recommendations of that metting are
reprinted below.

I. Basic Points Of Agreement
1. Emphasis is placed on the significance
of the usc of intellectual propeny systems os
a new formula for regulating North-South
economic relations in i&gt;
\trsuit of colonialist
interests..
2. For Indigenous peoples. the imel-

Vol 8 No.4

lcclltal propeny s}'Sicm means legitiJnation of the mis.'l.ppropriation of our peo·
pies' knowledge and resources for commercial purposes.
3. All aspects of the issue of intelleat"'ll
property (detenuin.'ltion of access tO nation·
~I resources. comrol of the knowledge or
cultural heritage of peoples. control of the
use of their resources :md regulation of the
tenns of exploitation) are aspects of self.
detem1ination. For Indigenous peoples,
:lCCOrdingly. the ultimate decision on this
issue is dependent on self--detenninc'ltion.
Positions taken under a tniSiecship regime
will be of a shon·teml nature.
4. Biodiversity :md a peoples knowledge
arc concepts inherent in the ide."- of
Indigenous tenitori:ility. Issues relating to
:t&lt;.'C\."'$5 10 t'e:SO\IrctS have to be viewed from
this Standpoint.
5. Integral Indigenous territoriality. its
recognition (or restormion) and its re&lt;.-onsti·
tution. arc prerequisites for enabling the cre:uivc and inven~h'c genius of each
Indigenous people tO flourish-and for it to
be meaningful to speak of proteaing such
peoples. The protection, rcconstlu.uion and
development of Indigenous knowledge sy.st~ms call for f~,tnher com.milmerll 1 the
0
effort to have these syStems reappraised by
the outside world.
6. Biodi,·ersity and the culture and lmel·
leaual property of • people are conctpts
that mean Indigenous territoriality. Issues
relating to access tO resources. and othe- s.
r
ha"c to be viewed from lhis standpo~nt.
7. For members of Indigenous peoples.
knowledge and dctemlin.1tion or the use of
resoun::cs are collective and intergtnera·
tior No fndigenous J)OP\Iialion. whether
1.1l.
of indhiduals or communities. nor the govemmem. can sell or transfer ownership of

resources which are the propeny of the people 3J&gt;d which each generation has on obligation 10 safeguard for the next.
8. Prevailing intellectual propeny systems
refle&lt;:t a conception and pma.ice that is;
o) colonialist, in th." the instruments of
the developed coumries are imposed in
order to appropriate the resources of
Indigenous peoples; b) mcist. in that it belittles and minimizes the value or our knowledge systems; c) UStlllXItory, in that it is
essentially a practice of theft.
9. AdjUSting Indigenous systems to the
pre,-ailing ime\lectu.'ll propeny systems (as a
world-wide concept and practice) changes
the Indigenous reguL1tory systems them·

selves.
10. Pot&lt;nts •nd Other intclloxtual propeny rights to fonns of life are wucccptable
to Indigenous peoples.
11. It is imponant to prevent conflicts
that may ~rise between communities from
the transformation of intelleaual property
into a means of di\'iding Indigenous unity.
12. There arc some fonnuL-.s that could
be used to enh.·mce the value of our prod·
uas (brand names, appellations o£ origin),
but on the undersro.nding that these are only
IY
tarkcting possibilities. not entailing
monopolies of the product or of ooU
ectivc
knowledge. There are also some proposals
for modifying prevailing imellectual property systems. such as the usc of cenificates of
origin. to prevent use of our resources \vith·
out our prior consent.
13. \ Ve mUSt prevent the use of current
systcnts of intellectual propeny from rot&gt;bing us. through monopoly rights. of
resources and knowledge in order to enrich
these &gt;)'stems and build up power opposed
toou.r own.
14. Work rm~ be conduaed Ol'l the
17

�PERSPECTIVES ON BIODIVERSITY AND INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY

design of a protoction and recognition sys·
tern whic-h is in accordance with the defense:
of our own CO!lception. and mechani.srns
mu.st be developed in the shon and medium
ICI'JT\ tO prevent appropriation of our

t-e:so&lt;trttS ond knowledge.
15. A system of protection ond nlC&lt;&gt;gni·
tion or our resources and knowledge rnUSt
be designed which is in confonn.ty with our
i
world view and contains fomlulas that, in
the shon and medh.\m tenn, ,...,ilJ pre\'ent the
appropriation or our resoUrttS by the countries of the Nonh ond Others.
16. There mliSl be appropri.'le mechanisms for maintaining and ensuring the

right of Indigenous peoples to deny indiscriminate access to the resources of our
communities or peoples. and making it possibte to contest patents or ocher exclusive

rights to what is essentially Indigenous...
17. Dise\tSSions regording intellectual
propeny should take place without distract·
ing us from priorities such as the struggle for
the right to tenitories and

self-detennilu~

tion. bearing in mind th.·u the Indigenous
popuL·uiott :u"'d the land foml ru1 indivisible
unity.

II. Short-Term Recommendations
J. Identify. analyze and systematically
evaluate from the standpoint of the
Indigenous world view difiere.Ol &lt;:Omt»
nems of the fom&gt;al imelleetual propeny sys·
tenlS. including mech..misms, instrumems
·
and forurns. among which we h.1ve:
a) Intellectual propeny mochanisms
Patents, Trademark. Authors' rights.
Rights of de\'Ciopers or new plant vari·
eties. Commercial secretS. lndusui:.ll
design. ubels of origin.
b) lmell«:tual propcny Instruments
The Agreement on Trade-Related
lmem.1lional Propeny RightS (TRIPS) of
the General 1\greemem on Tariffs and
Tr:lde (GA'Ii); The Convention. on
Biodive~ty, " 'th special emphasiS on
the following aspects: cm•ronmemal
impact .1s.sessmems. subsidiary scieotiftc
body, technological council, monitoring.
nation.1..l studies and protocols, as well as
on rightS or fam&gt;ers and ex situ control
of genn pl-lsm. which are nOt covered
18

w1der the Convention.
c) lmell«:tml propeny forums
O¢Hne mechanisms for oonsult.1.tion and
exchange of infonntuion betv..·een
Indigenous organizations and imemational forums such as the: Tn.-aty for
Am..uoni..m Cooperation. Andean Pact.
General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade.
European Patents Corwenuon. United
Nations Commission on SUSI~inable
Developmem. Union for the. Protecdon
of New Varieties or Plams. V..' rld
o
Intellectual Propeny Organization
(WIPO).
lnternatiOMl
l-'lbor
Organization (ILO). United Nations
Commission on Human Rights.
2. E' "luate the possibilities offered by
Lhe intemadonotl instruments embodying
cuhuml. political. environmental Md other
lightS that could be incorporated into a sui
genelis le&amp;~l framework for the prot«:tion of
lndigcnotiS resou=s and knowledge.
3. DeHne the comem or consultations
with such forums.
4. Define the feasibility of using some
mechanisms of the prevailing imelleaual
property systems. in relation 10 protection of
biologicallgenetic resourocs and marketing
of nlSO\&gt;rttS.
5. Study the feasibility or alternative systenlS and mechanisms for protecting
lndigenous interestS in our own resources
and knowledge: sui gcnelis systems for protection of inu::Ueetu."ll propeny; inventors'
cenificate. model kgisl-ltion on folklore;
new deposit standards for material entering
genn pl1.Sm lxmks: commissioner ror imellectu.~ propeny rights; tribunals; bi.lmcral
and muhil.:neml contraCtS or oorwentions:
m:neria)s transfer agn..""&lt;:nlClliS; biological
prospecting: defensive publianiOI'l cenific:ues of origin.
6 . Seek to m.'lke alternative s)'Slems
operational " 'thin the shon tem1, by estab·
lishing a minimal regulatory framework (for
example bilateral comracts).
7. Systemattcally study. or e.\1xmd stud·
ies already conducted or. the dynamics or
Indigenous peoples. with emphasis on: basis
for suscainability (territories. culn.u·e. economy); use or knowledge and r&lt;SOUI"&lt;X$ (col·
lecth't ownership systems. community usc

of resources): contmunit)'. l'tation.."tl. regional
and intem..1tional o~ni.zation:ll bases.
These
make it possible to create
mechanisms wilhin and outside Indigenous
peoples cap:W!e of assigning the same value
to Indigenous knowledge. ans and crafts as
lO western science.
8 . Establish regional and local
lnd1ge:rlous ~dvisory bodies on intellectual
propcny :Uld biodive~ty " 1th functions
involving legal a&lt;h~&lt;e . lllOtlitoring. productjon and disscn\il\.1tion of inJom'l:ation, ~'d
production of m.:11erials.
9. 1demify natiorml imcUectual property organiza.tions. especially in areas of biod.i·

""II

versit)t

lO.ldentify and draw up a timel3ble of
forums for discltSSion and exchange or
infonnalion on imelleclual propeny ancVor
biodiversity. Seek suppon for sending
Indigenous dele&amp;~tes to panicipate in such
forums. An effon will be nude to obt:tin
information wilh a viC\V tO the C\•entual
establishment of an lnfomt.1tion, Training
and Dissemination Center on Indigenous
Propeny at1d Ethical Guides on contraCt
ncg&lt;Xiation and model contmclS.
Ill. Medium-Term Strategies
I. PLm. program. establish timetables
and seek finatlCing for the establishment or
an Indigenous program for the collective use
and protection of biological resourttS and
knowledge. This program \\111 be de\-eloped
in phases acoording to geographic areas.
2. Plan, draw up timctab!es for and
hold seminars and workshops at the com·
munity, national and regionol levels on biodive~ty and prevailing imell«:tual propeny
systems and altemati\'es.
3. Establish a pctmanem consuhalive
mechanism Unkir~s community workers
and Indigenous leadel'$. 3S well as :m infor~
matkm net,vork.
4. Train Indigenous leaders in aspectS
or imellectual propeny and biodive~ty.
5. Draw 11p ~ Legal Protocol of
Indigenous law on the use and community
knowledge of biological resourttS.
6. Develop a strntero• for dissemination
of this l.eg.1l Protocol at t.he nationol and
in lC.m:uional levels.
Abya Yala News

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="51">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="27240">
                  <text>Vol. 8, no. 4 (Winter 1994)</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27599">
                <text>Amazonian Peoples on Biodiversity and IPR</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="51">
            <name>Type</name>
            <description>The nature or genre of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27600">
                <text>Journal Article</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27601">
                <text>Winter 1994</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="44">
            <name>Language</name>
            <description>A language of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27602">
                <text>English</text>
              </elementText>
              <elementText elementTextId="46707">
                <text>English</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
      <elementSet elementSetId="5">
        <name>Zotero</name>
        <description/>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="314">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27603">
                <text>Amazonian Peoples on Biodiversity and IPR</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="217">
            <name>Item Type</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27604">
                <text>Journal Article</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="319">
            <name>Volume</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27605">
                <text>8</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="264">
            <name>Issue</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27606">
                <text>4</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="283">
            <name>Pages</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27607">
                <text>17-18</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="293">
            <name>Publication Title</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27608">
                <text>Abya Yala News: Journal of the South and Meso American Indian Rights Center (SAIIC)</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="221">
            <name>ISSN</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27609">
                <text>1071-3182</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="246">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27610">
                <text>Winter 1994</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="269">
            <name>Language</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27611">
                <text>English</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="222">
            <name>Abstract Note</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27612">
                <text>The Coordinating Body of Indigenous Communities of the Amazon Basin settled on several basic points of agreement regarding indigenous positions and strategies relevant to biodiversity and intellectual property rights issues at a regional meeting in Bolivia.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="322">
            <name>Attachment Title</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27613">
                <text>Amazonian_peoples_on_biodiversity_and_ipr.pdf</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="323">
            <name>Attachment URL</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27614">
                <text>[No URL]</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="157">
        <name>Biodiversity</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="337">
        <name>Coordinating Body of Indigenous Communities of the Amazon Basin</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="20">
        <name>Human Rights</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="296">
        <name>Intellectual Property Rights</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="1695" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="568">
        <src>https://www.abyayalanews.org/files/original/03b31eb63ef9e1c8d4ab0d4f5f10a67f.pdf</src>
        <authentication>41917f6f35fe99fc1a6fc8cac60bfd3c</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="6">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="324">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="29907">
                    <text>P ERSPECTIVES ON BIODIVERSITY AND

I NT.,_LL EC_,_UA L_,__,,O PE,R_,_' -- - - - - - - - - - - E, , o, T"'= P R , _, TY

Biodiversity, Community Integrity
and t he Second Colonialist Wave
He whare maikhi tu ki roto ki te tuwatawata. he tou no te rengatira: he whare maihi tu ki te
wa kie te paenga. he kai na te ahi.
An ancestral house standing inside the community is the sign of chiefliness: one standing in
the open is food for fire.
- Maori Proverb

by A T P
roha e areake M
ead

M

the Maori proverb above indi-

tes. an ancestral house. or any
pe&lt;:t of heritage which restS

within its home community. holds in

itself and brings

lO

its people numa-

AroJta Tt Pm·wkc Mead is a Maori aclivi.st and
works wi1h Taonga Umittd in Ac&gt;tcoara, Nt."W
Zealand.
6

respect and sovereignty. If the house or
any other aspect of heritage. either tangible or intangible, is taken away from
its community and from its context, it
becomes at risk of destruction. "food for
the lire."' And its people are confined to
• destiny of mourning for the loss of a
beloved and irreplaceable pan of their

heritage.

For Indigenous communities. the
underlying meaning in this pro\·erb is

that the life force of that heritage still
exists regardless of the physico! circum-

stances around it An ancestral house
will always be part or the heritage or ilS
own tribal community even if it now

fomlS pan of a national or imemational
museum collection.
#Jya Yala News

�PERSPECTIVES ON BIODIVERSITY AND INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY

An Indigenous plant. its extracts and
seeds. will always be part of the heritage
or the community, who have imerncted
with it for so many generations that the
plant has become j&gt;art of the language of
that community, its significance reafGrmed daily in (waiata) songs.
(whakatauki) proverbs and (whaikorero) traditional greetings.

The Second Wave of
Colonization
The first wave of colonization consisted of the forced misappropriation of
Indigenous lands and resources. most
often through ,·iolence, resulting in
mass alienation of Indigenous peoples
from their homelands and heritage. The
denigration of Indigenous vah,tes and
practices was sanctioned by religious
and social beliefs that tribal peoples
(non-Christi:ms) were savages and barbarians, and 1heir cuhurnl traditions
"'heathen'" and evil. Settlers claimed that
theft of Indigenous lands served the
.. public good'" and that new technology
promised more effective land usc.
improved farming methods. and new
crops. Time proved, however. lhat new
farming technology kept being
impro\'ed until most farmers could no
longer afford it. New methods also
brought soil erosion. pesticide pollution. and the final insult. ha'"ing to buy
seeds which were prc,riously 53.\'Cd ftom
the harvest. Where Mother Earth used
to be the equalizer for those who used
her resources to feed, clothe. shelter and
heal themseh'es and others, technology
has turned her imo a factory.
The second wa\'C of colonization sets
its sights on mis.'1pptopriating what little
remains after the first wave. the "'intctl'\gibles" of Indigenous cultuteslndigenous knowledge of the environment. pre"entative and curative healing
practices. and panicularly traditional
uses of Indigenous plants (medicines.
dyes. complimentary crops to name but
a fcw).\Vhere the first wave of colonization was made possible by nonnalizing
the violence against Indigenous peoples
Vol. 8 No.4

as in the service of "the public good,"
the second wave is accommodated and
encouraged through national and intcrn:nional legal instruments which allow
st~ucs and privme companies to exercise-through legal and financial nonns
and standards~xternal private and
exclusive ownership of 1he tangible and
imangible heritage of Indigenous communities. liS not at all coincidental that
the jus1ification of this misappropriation
is the s..1.me: "It's for humanit)'. for the
public good ." Before. it was land acqui·
s1tion. Now. it is acquisition of knowledge and resources. No matter how one
·
looks at it, the result is the s..u ne: outsiders forcing the concepts of commodification of resources and acquiring ownership of the ancestors· gifts-lands,
resources and knowledge.

Cultural and Intellectual
Property Rights
Governments as well as private companies are now clamoring to copyright
and patem Indigenous an forms. medicinal plants. languages and even genetic
materials. Signatory states to the
Convention on Biological Diversity and
the UN Conference on Environment &amp;
Developmem's Agenda 21 (1992) are
now required to respect and take measures to protect the Intellectual Propcny
Rights (IPR) of Indigenous peoples and
local communities with respect to bio·
logical diversity. Many States have inter·
preted these international directives as
justifying the redesign of their national
IPR legislation to legalize State governance of community assets. but
Indigenous peoples around the world
view such measures as unnecessar)'
intrusions into the integrity of their
communities.
h is neither logical nor practical that
the best system for the protection of the
cultural and intellectual property or
Indigenous peoples resides with states
or even with the international community. Protection can onty be designed
and implemented by Indigenous commul1ities themselves in panncrship with

individuals and organizations (local,
national. regiomll and international) of
their choosing on an informed consent
basis. The body most c.•pable of respect·
ing and enhancing the unique needs of
an Indigenous community is one initiated. developed and staffed by the community itself. National and international instruments cannot possibly prepare
communities for the challenges upon
theit own stro.ctures of leadership and
accountability. State instro.mcnts should
focus on the activities and proccdtu·cs of
companies, bm it is clear that many
States would prefer to regulate the
activities of communities. At a funda·
mental level there is al.s o the problem of
states. as well as the international comrnunity. assuming that they have a right
to develop standards and legally binding instruments for assets which do not
belong to them.

New threats facing Indigenous
Communities: A Case Study
The attack on Indigenous communi~
tics is constant and significant.
Indigenous communities cannot afford
to ignore external pressure and simply
to hope that ignoring the threats will in
time make them go aw-a)~ A brief examination of the national activities and
c.xpericnces of the Indigenous communities living in just 01'e UN member
State-New Zealand-demonstrates the
diversity of IPR issues facing Indigenous
communities.
The human genome contains the
heritage not just of an individual but of
that person's community. for many
Indigenous peoples. the concept of
"'ownership"' of a human gene e\'en by
the individual is just not accepted. The
ownership of a human gene by a company is therefore reprehensible. \ Vithin
the Pacific. two attempts have already
been made to patent Indigenous human
genetic material (Solomon Islands and
the Hagahai or Papua New Guinea). The
Human Genome Diversity Project has
targeted over 200 South PaciGc
Indigenous communities for genetic
7

�PERSPECTIVES ON BIODIVERSITY AND INTELLECTU~~ P R O P E~ TY ------------A L....!'-!~::!:.! R~~

sampling. Maori arc one of the few not
on che lise (See arcicle on HGD Projccc
pg. 13, eds.). However. che a11cmpced
recommendation to the New Zealand

government

by

Maori-that

New

Zealand discuss with other Pacific
nations the itnplications of the collection of human genetic materials in the
Pacific-fell on deaf cars.
Research within New Zealand on

cancer. alcoholism and otitis media
(gl\lc car) has been reponed to focus on
Maori genetic predispositions lO such

conditions. In the hands of health
insurance companies. genetic screening
on the basis of ethnicity involves fundamental human rights issues which have
yet to be c., plored.

Copyright of Indigenous
Languages
In November 1994. che Oxford
University Press attempted to secure an
cxcl\lsivc copyright or che \Vi/limns
Maori Umguagc Dicrionary. First pub·
lished in l$44. the dictiOI''I:U)' remains
the most authorilative dictionary of the
Maori language. ll has been reprinted
twelve times (seven editions) by the
New Zealand Go'"ernmcnt Print Office,
an agency established to promote the
recording and publishing of New
Ze3land hiscory for the benefit of all
New Ze~landers.
Many of che first Maori language and
~...laori history publications were financed
and p11blished by a state- owned Printing
Office on the underscanding that such
publications were "held in trust~ as vital
components of the national herilage.
Prh'3tization of state agencies, including
the Print Office. has opened 11p Maori
publicatior\S to copyright by the privace
sector. There are currently no mechanisms by which Maori can regain ownership. We will have to fight for each publication individually.

Traditional Uses of Indigenous
Flora and Fauna
Several New Zealand companies
8

have developed successful cosmetic
products using tradicional knowledge of
nora and fa\llla. A ncdging phannaccucical induscry is also being developed.
but at this point the cos1nctic propcnics
of native plants are the primary ulrget of
commercial exploitation. ln some cases
the traditional knowledge comes from
Indigenous informants. in other cases
through research in historical records
kept by early senlers-includingchosc of
Capcain james Cook himself-which
provide detailed and illustrated
accounts of the properties and uses of
native plants.
The Body Shop recently negotiated
with a small tribal company their
extraction process for the oil of the
native Manulla plant. Manuka is a native
plant common to most of the North
Island and of significance 10 many different tribes. such that songs, proverbs,
weavings and other art fonns record the
plant's special relationship to each tribe.
Thus. from a tribal point of view. it is
diffic\llt to accepc the validity of any IPR
agreement bet ween two companies
involving what most Maori would consider "common propcny."' Exploitation
itself is easier to understand than the
attempt to patent the process. or tO seck
plant variety rights on the Manuk..1.
Already. plant variety rights have
been granted to national and international companies for thincen plants by
the New Zealand government. In
response, the Maori have filed a Treaty
of \.Yaitangi Tribunal Claim against the
go'"erntnent . seeking confirmation that
all native plams are the heritage of
Maori tribes in the first place. and that
any decisions relating to the conmlercialization of native plants must by
made by Maori tribes themselves. This
historical case is due for consideration
in mid-1995.

Capacity Building:
More Questions Than Answers
The righcco intellectual property. as a
western legal invention. was never

designed co cope with the myriad ·properties"" now being thrust upon it.
Indigenous knowledge and Indigenous
resources simply do not fit into che IPR
regime. Protection of heritage must be
addressed through alternative mechanisms. but it must be a mechanism
robust enough to apply to the diverse
range of activities now thremening the
heritage and livelihoods of Indigenous
communities.
Indigenous communities need to son
out amongst themselves-without the
interference of non·members-the tribal.
sub-tribal and ramily "ownership.. of
knowledge. \ \That is common property?
Who has the right to give consent?
Elders or youth? Tribal political structures or new additional specialiSt tribal
organizations? \Vhat structures will they
put in place? Should regional and
national scruccures also be established?
By whom?
Indigenous communities should also
make greater use of the infonnation
highwa)' and strengthen national,
regional and international networks in
order to exchange information. offer
advice and experience. and keep
informed of the growing swell of che
second wave of colonization - misappropriation of Indigenous knowledge
and biodiversity.
The most appropriate and resultsoriented contribution that states and the
imernational community could offer is
to provide additional financing for com·
munity capacity-building. and to focus
regulatory attention on external compa·
nics. agencies, and individuals.
As the Maori proverb scates. the heritage of Indigenous communities rests
with those communities. If any aspect of
this heritage is removed, it becomes
food for the fire. Similarity. the proverb
reminds us that che incegrity of a commul'lity requires us to hold firm and protect the treasures of the ancestors. If
pans of our heritage have been lost. it is
our responsibility to get them back. no
matter how long il takes.

Abya Yala News

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="51">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="27240">
                  <text>Vol. 8, no. 4 (Winter 1994)</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27725">
                <text>Biodiversity, Community Integrity and the Second Colonialist Wave</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="51">
            <name>Type</name>
            <description>The nature or genre of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27726">
                <text>Journal Article</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="39">
            <name>Creator</name>
            <description>An entity primarily responsible for making the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27727">
                <text>Aroha Te Pareake Mead</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27728">
                <text>1994</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="44">
            <name>Language</name>
            <description>A language of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27729">
                <text>English</text>
              </elementText>
              <elementText elementTextId="46714">
                <text>English</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
      <elementSet elementSetId="5">
        <name>Zotero</name>
        <description/>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="314">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27730">
                <text>Biodiversity, Community Integrity and the Second Colonialist Wave</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="217">
            <name>Item Type</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27731">
                <text>Journal Article</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="190">
            <name>Author</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27732">
                <text>Aroha Te Pareake Mead</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="319">
            <name>Volume</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27733">
                <text>8</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="264">
            <name>Issue</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27734">
                <text>4</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="283">
            <name>Pages</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27735">
                <text>6-8</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="293">
            <name>Publication Title</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27736">
                <text>SAIIC Newsletter</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="221">
            <name>ISSN</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27737">
                <text>1071-3182</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="246">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27738">
                <text>1994</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="269">
            <name>Language</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27739">
                <text>English</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="222">
            <name>Abstract Note</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27740">
                <text>Indian communities are now faced with the task of defending their cultural and intellectual property rights in the areas of agriculture, language, genetics, etc.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="322">
            <name>Attachment Title</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27741">
                <text>Biodiversity_community_integrity.pdf</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="323">
            <name>Attachment URL</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27742">
                <text>[No URL]</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="297">
        <name>Colonialism</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="298">
        <name>Copyright</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="296">
        <name>Intellectual Property Rights</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="1683" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="698">
        <src>https://www.abyayalanews.org/files/original/1effd5dca26553ed0191a3539be6eb92.pdf</src>
        <authentication>58108704d3aa42c0c35ad4f0eedeb5f5</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="6">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="324">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="30032">
                    <text>PERSPECTIVES ON BIODIVERSITY AND INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY

Guidelines for
Biodiversity
Collections:
A Look at the
Issues

by M
elissa Nelson
here is no place where the clash
between the exploitation of, and
balance with, the naturnl world is
more pronounced than in the struggles
of the world's Indigenous peoples. As
the colonial power elite tighten their
grip on the remaining "natural
resources ... they arc discovering that it is
Indigenous people who hold the secretS
to the many uses and benefits of plant
and animal communities. An age·old

T

war is ensuing between two world views
and ways of lh•ing: one that believes
humans are the pinnacle of evolution
and chat our ultimate purpose is l O con·
trol and enslave nature: the other that
Lhc human mind will never completely
comprehend, much less control. the

do is sensitively observe EarthS naturnl
C)•cles and work to harmonize \Vhh
them.
It is surprising to many people thot

this war of world views is not onl)• seen
in the obvious pl"ces of educational
philosophies. economic theories, and
religious and political syswns, but in
the seemingly benign realm of ecological
conscl"\~ation.

After aH 1 3S Australian

biologiSl Roger Kitching has said, ·conservation is jusl as much a use as are

agriculture, forestry, and urban de,·elop·
n'ICnt." Highly diverse :Hcas arc m
demand by u·a.nsnational corporntions
who seek to control the

world~ remr~in·

ing resources. by conservation groups

forces of nature and that the best we can

who intend to protect their ecological
significance. and by researchers who
wish to study these areas. 'Who decides

MeltSsa Nd.so11 is pan Ojibwc arul works as

which areas are designated for constrva·

c.xccutivc director of
Ccnsuvancy in California.

tion? How are these mauei'S decided?
When are the local Indigenous people

Vol. 8 No. 4

The

Culwral

involved? When do they initiate such
efforts? Arc they in control of their ternwrie-s. or are conservation organizations
in control? 1'hese are some or the ques·
Lions raised br conOicts surrounding
l~nd use in Indigenous territories.

Reigning in the
Bioprospectors?
\Vhen capitalism and conservation
nlCCl. omsider·tapitalis.ts unfortunately
enjoy n&gt;any advantages. as well as
opportunitit.!S to reapply paternalistic
auitudes that .. modern \Veste.mers"
know best how to manage kmds.
Consequently. an increasing number or
concerned people (both native and nonnative) arc discussing and proposing
ways to protect Indigenous peoples'
knowledge and biological resources
from exploitation br the various comp.:1·
nics. governments. and academic. devcl·
opment and research institmions seek·

19

�PERSPECTIVES ON B IODIVERSITY AND INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY

ing access to biodiversity infonnation

and native knowledge.
Organi.zations and individuals have
met, u.n der diverse sponsors, including
the Third World Network, Zuni
Conservation Project, Pew Scholars

Program, World Wide Fund for Nature,
and Nati"e Seeds/SEARCH, to discuss
formation or ethical guidelines to over..
see the relationship between "prospector" and "steward." Underlying these

effons is a common feeling

that

bio-

prospe&lt;:tors are already grabbing biolog·
ical material as fast as they can and that
some process is needed to ensure a
cooperative, just, and mutually beneficial relationship. Enforceable guidelines
for bioprospecting are one component
o[ the complex process or negotiating
the equitable exchange o[ infonnation

and rtcSources.
Some Indigenous activists, however.

human and land rights violations. From
phannaceuti~l comrncts to international treaties · such as the Biodiversity
Convention, we see governments, cotpormions. research institutes. NGOs.
and other groups beginning to rc-eva.luate how they relate to and "'do bw;iness"
'vith Indigenous peoples. and begin·
ning, at le-ast, to pay lip--service. to
Indigenous intellectual propeny rights
and benefit-sharing. Indigenous peoples
worldwide arc meeting, organizing, and
taking leadership roles in determining
the nature of these relalionships. Here I
point out some questions and issues to
considet when reading, discussing, or
assisting with the writing or ethical
guidelines for biodiversity prospecting.

General Considerations for
Guidelines

To begin with , the definition, purfeel that creating such g1.1idclines will pose. and scope or the guidelines must
only condone and increase exploitation be clearly set out. For example. do the
of biodiversity and Indigenous knowl- guidelines. cover only biodiversity infor·
edge. It could do so by giving bio· mation, or do they cover situations
prospectors a legitimate use-document where a bioprospector seeks access to
to rationalize and cover up their colo- knowledge about the uses of biodi\'ersi·
nialist. and, in Native American histori- ty? What is actually mea.m by biodiveran Jack 0. Forbes' view, ..cannibalistic," sity-plants, animals and fungi , or other
intent. {look at the comtpt uses of biological entities such as microorganEnvironmental Impact Statements.) I isms or cell lines? How will guidelines
cnn see both points of ,ricw. but sub- be enforced? What system of compli·
scribe more to the belief that we have to ance will be used? What legal frameaddress the heedless bioprospecting work should be established? What i.nsti·
already occurring within indigenous ter- tutions are subject to the guidelines?
ritories and do something about h. Even Who decides these questions?
though many bioprospectors exhibit
"the disease of aggression against. and Critical Components
consumption of. living things... we canIn 3ny biodiversity accessing situa·
not let lear of the ·other" paral&gt;••e us tion. one must Stan with an explon\tory
and pre,•em cooperative efforts toward phase. I believe this to be the most crit·
change.
ical Slagc to regulate. Any guidelines
A diverse set o[ ethical guidelines, must define how the appropriate
contracts. uta.ties. and other dmft docu- Indigenous authorities arc selected. For
ments have appeared in recem years in example. different situations might
response to Indigenous protest of require prospectors to approach any
20

combination of Indigenous national.
regional, sub·regional or conllnunity
organizations. The exploratory phase
should serve to introduce the potential
user. as well as their intentions. interests. and methods to the appropriate
authority. At the community level, the
reasons for requesting access to biodi~
versity information should be revealed
to the entire community, to tmditional
leaders, and in the local langllagc or the
co1nm\lllity being approached. A project
document should be presented which
discloses the foreseeable consequences
:lnd commercial interests of the.
research. and a description of the meth·
ods to be used.
Following this disclosure. 1hc bioprospector should inquire whether the
community or its represemativcs wish to
tenninate or continue with negotiations.
If the. community agrees to lhe involve.~
ment with the bioprospector. then other
issues, especially the terms of compenS.1tion, must be clearly outlined.
The question is. docs the. accessing
p.1rty have the ethics to honor and
respect the oommunity·S deei.sion? If the
desire to cooperate wilh 3Jld show
respect for Earth's divci"$C' manifestations
and peoples were currently presem .
then l wouldn't be writing this. How do
we instill I he absolute imponance of this
basic respect for life in the "cannibals" of
first world capitalism? I do not know,
but we must start somewhere. Many
acti\'iSts think that "talk is cheap" but by
discussing this with a wide variety of
people, and aniculating the deep ethical
issues involved with this complex situation, we may begin to shed light on 1he
subject and inadvcnently educate those
who need to hear it.
F()r rrt.OI'c information contact: Titt Cultural
Constt\'MC)I, P.O. Bcx 72086. Davis, CA
95617. (916) 759-2285.jax: (916) 759-2268.
fW.(a Yala News

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="51">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="27240">
                  <text>Vol. 8, no. 4 (Winter 1994)</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27507">
                <text>Guidelines for Biodiversity Collections: A Look at the Issues</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="51">
            <name>Type</name>
            <description>The nature or genre of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27508">
                <text>Journal Article</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="39">
            <name>Creator</name>
            <description>An entity primarily responsible for making the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27509">
                <text>Melissa Nelson</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27510">
                <text>Winter 1994</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="44">
            <name>Language</name>
            <description>A language of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27511">
                <text>English</text>
              </elementText>
              <elementText elementTextId="46702">
                <text>English</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
      <elementSet elementSetId="5">
        <name>Zotero</name>
        <description/>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="314">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27512">
                <text>Guidelines for Biodiversity Collections: A Look at the Issues</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="217">
            <name>Item Type</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27513">
                <text>Journal Article</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="190">
            <name>Author</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27514">
                <text>Melissa Nelson</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="319">
            <name>Volume</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27515">
                <text>8</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="264">
            <name>Issue</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27516">
                <text>4</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="283">
            <name>Pages</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27517">
                <text>19-20</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="293">
            <name>Publication Title</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27518">
                <text>Abya Yala News: Journal of the South and Meso American Indian Rights Center (SAIIC)</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="221">
            <name>ISSN</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27519">
                <text>1071-3182</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="246">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27520">
                <text>Winter 1994</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="269">
            <name>Language</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27521">
                <text>English</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="222">
            <name>Abstract Note</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27522">
                <text>Indigenous communities are often caught in the cross hairs of different interest groups struggling to control ecologically diverse territories. Conflicts over the use of indigenous territories raises many important questions regarding the rights of Indian communities.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="322">
            <name>Attachment Title</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27523">
                <text>Guidelines_for_biodiversity_collections.pdf</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="323">
            <name>Attachment URL</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27524">
                <text>[No URL]</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="320">
        <name>Bioprospecting</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="295">
        <name>Conservationism</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="296">
        <name>Intellectual Property Rights</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="61">
        <name>land rights</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="1693" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="688">
        <src>https://www.abyayalanews.org/files/original/48270ba45a1066bd5b83e7847896dd32.pdf</src>
        <authentication>4afbca1365f2ea20309aa0b4c64294a4</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="6">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="324">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="30022">
                    <text>I N TE RNA T I O NAL

Mapuche at Summit of
the Americas:
"We Oppose the FreeTrade Agreement."

edge at the service of the nonhern coun-

tt)'S transnationals...
This declaration sprung from a con·
fercnce held in No\·ember in Temuco.
#

Chile. It begins, "In this declaration. we
establish a political position before
NAFTA. In March, we will hold another
meeting to el. borate a set of proposals to
a
guarantee Indigenous rights in relation
to the free-trade agreements. \Ve arc
holding a series of consultations.
because we wam everyone to be fully

We alert the Indigenous peoples of America that the multilateral economic agreements which are being adopted by the Latin American
governments compromise the future of the continent. in which the
Indigenous peoples are a reality that possess historical legitimacy over
awa_e of any plan. program or project
r
the territories in which the governing states have been established.
derived from the free trade :\greement
-Consejo de Todas las Tierras. Declaration of Temuco. Dec. 2. 1994 and applied in Mapuche territory. But in
addition, we wam guarantees for our
uring the Summit of the ended." Huilcam~n noted. "but this war righlS. This rna&gt;' cause confliCtS with the
Americas. President Clinton of ecor\omic competition is more dan· state, and of course. the communities are
announced the future entry of . gcrous, more harmful. more e.ffec;tive. going to defend themselves. This conOict
may have unpredictable resultS.•
Chile into the Nonh American Free more destabilizing."
· we p.1rticipated in the Summit-stat·
Trade Agreement. AucAn Hui1cam.&lt;1n and
)ost N:.t.fn. tWO representatives or the ed Huil~mctn-in order to make our Other States W ill Soon Follow
ln the Summit, the states announced
Mapuche Indian organization in Chile. physical and cultural existence known,
Consejo de Todas las Tierra.s (Council of even when the States and in panicular development of an act ion plan to review
All the Lands). p resented a formal decla- the Chilean state say that there are only and improve the laws that protect the
ration to those at the Summit, denounc- Chileans here. We demonstrated that in rights of minorities and the Indigenous
ing the multilateral agreement as illegit· Chile there is another realit)• apan from peoples, but according to Huilcam:ln
.
imate. since the states have no authority the unifomlity that the State is trying to :.'lnd NaJn, this is ..just a way to make the

D

o ver their people. The declaration
affirms that the states can legitimately
meet to discuss the free·trade agreemem, but cannot unilaterally make
decisions that affect Indigenous peoples.
"The Indigenous people arc a rMiity. We
p redate the states. We pre-date the governments that today make decisions for

us and for the comincrn ... at the same
time. those agreements are foreign. uni·
lateral. and lack our consent."
Huilc:anu1n and Nafn came to the
Summit representing hundreds of thou·
sands of Mapuche who fear that NAFTA
will increase the exploitation of their territories and the violation of their human
rights. NAFTA. they point out. was
signed in the US. Canada and Mexico
without taking the Indigenous peoples

into account. According to the ·~·1apuche.
representatives. the economic agenda
p roposed at the Summit, will ha,·e terrib le repercussions for Indigenous peoples. "They say that the cold war has

Vol. 8 No.4

impose. Chile has twelve million inhabitants, according to the government four

million live in poveny.
One million of these arc Mapuche. In
the long term, the people most affected
by the trade agreement with Chile, as in
all of America ";11 be the Indigenous
peoples. In this sense. we are concenled
for the future of the continent. We have
found that there is no information-there
is little understanding of the implications o f these multilateral agreements.
Today for example. people arc
patenting food produCtS. but they arc
also patenting Indigenous knowledge,
even human gene5. When we lose control of these things, it will be a global
catastrophe." Under NAFTA. the decla·
ration states. "the intellectual propeny
of the Indigenous peoples will continue
to be usurped with gre.1ter efficiency. in
light of that fact that biotechnology has

become the mechanism and wol of
usu_pation and extraction of our knowl·
r

public believe that the states "ill respect
our rights."'
Follo"ing the Summit. Huilcam:\n and
Naln spoke at a number of eventS. emphasizing that while Chile may be the nextsig·
natory to NAFTA. many other Latin
American sutes arc li!l&lt;'d up to follow.
Sooner or later. all Indigenous peoples " 'II

be foced with the s.1.me circumstances.
Thus. the Consejo de Todas las Tierras
hopes to es~ablish alliances with other

Indian organizations to promote action
now- before the agreements arc signed and
it is too L"e. Huilcrun~n notes that the
Indigenous movement has been too often

o-n the defensive. reacting

L
O

eventS after

the fact. NAFTA, he urges. should be met
" ;th an Indigenous offensive.
To support the Mapuchc effort against NAFTA
contact: Aukin \\~llmapu Ngulam·Conscjo de
Todas las Titrras. Gtncral M'ac.kt Pma 152
Casflla +18 Tcmuco, Chile
TcVjax: (45) 235697.
25

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="51">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="27240">
                  <text>Vol. 8, no. 4 (Winter 1994)</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27691">
                <text>Mapuche at Summit of the Americas: "We Oppose the Free Trade Agreement"</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="51">
            <name>Type</name>
            <description>The nature or genre of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27692">
                <text>Journal Article</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27693">
                <text>Winter 1994</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="44">
            <name>Language</name>
            <description>A language of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27694">
                <text>English</text>
              </elementText>
              <elementText elementTextId="46712">
                <text>English</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
      <elementSet elementSetId="5">
        <name>Zotero</name>
        <description/>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="314">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27695">
                <text>Mapuche at Summit of the Americas: "We Oppose the Free Trade Agreement"</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="217">
            <name>Item Type</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27696">
                <text>Journal Article</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="319">
            <name>Volume</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27697">
                <text>8</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="264">
            <name>Issue</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27698">
                <text>4</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="283">
            <name>Pages</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27699">
                <text>25</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="293">
            <name>Publication Title</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27700">
                <text>SAIIC Newsletter</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="221">
            <name>ISSN</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27701">
                <text>1071-3182</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="246">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27702">
                <text>Winter 1994</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="269">
            <name>Language</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27703">
                <text>English</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="222">
            <name>Abstract Note</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27704">
                <text>After the announcement of Chile's entry into the North American Free Trade Agreement, indigenous groups speak out against the potential economic and territorial consequences of the agreement for indigenous communities.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="322">
            <name>Attachment Title</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27705">
                <text>Mapuche_at_Summit_of_the_Americas.pdf</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="323">
            <name>Attachment URL</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27706">
                <text>[No URL]</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="23">
        <name>Chile</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="296">
        <name>Intellectual Property Rights</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="22">
        <name>Mapuche</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="109">
        <name>NAFTA</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="1692" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="689">
        <src>https://www.abyayalanews.org/files/original/fbbb761959390b5a615a9b0deee03998.pdf</src>
        <authentication>4f1205f1b4ea24f00c7f6842ee3c487e</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="6">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="324">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="30023">
                    <text>PERSPECTIVES ON BIODIVERSITY AND INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY

Safeguarding
Indigenous Knowledge:
Intellectual Property Rights and
the Search for a New Framework
by Darrell A. Posey

afeguarding 1raditional knowledge

S

:1nd

biogenetic

resources

has

become a ccntr1!1 struggle in the
expression of Indigenous self-detCm1ination. V.lhitc il is a growing "''"''areness

of dte scale of 1&gt;ast and prcsem misap·
propriation by science. industry and
other commercial interests that has pro,.
voked

this

concern,

tr3ditional

resoutces arc also increasingly sec1'l as
the basis for greater political autonomy
and economic self-sufficiency.
lmcllecll!al Propert)' Rights. or IPR,

has been proposed as a 1cgal ins1 nunem
under which Indigenous peoples could
seek protection for ki\Owledgc and
resources. IPR developed as a western
concept to protect individual, techno·
logical and industrial invemions. The
dangers lying within the IPR debate are
well recognized b)' Indigenous peoples.
Dr. D&lt;zrrtll PO!&lt;. has many ytar$' txptritncc
)'
working on IPR a11d biodi\'crsity issues. and is
currtmly with tht WOrking Group on

Tr·aditional Rtsoura Riglus

al

Lhe Oxford

Centre fOJ· Envirunmcnl. ElhiC$. and Society at

Oxford Un11·ersiry.
Vol. 8 No.4

who, along wilh m~ny other researchers.
a) Global funding for ex-plo itation:
think that IPR is not an appropriate First. the Earth Summit (United N3tions
mee:h3.nism to strengthen and empo,ver Conrercnce on Environment and
troditional and Indigenous peoples.
Development), held in Rio de Janeiro in
The term Tradilional Resource June. 1992. dealt in large pan with how
Rights. or TRR, has emerged from the biological diversity conservation could
debate around IPR to describe a broader. be economically exploited through
human-rights b:tsed concept composed biotechnological development. and
of the "bundles of rights" taken from effectively highlighted the economic
other international instruments and JX&gt;tCntial of traditional knowledge and
agreements (including IPR). TRR is a resources. The Convention on Biological
£'irst attempt 10 define and idemify 10 Diversit)' which emerged from the
what extent existing international cus· Summit calls for the study. use, and
tomal)' law and practice c..1.n be used to application o( "traditional knowledge.
defend Indigenous knowledge and bio- innov~tions. and pr:lClie:es." Its :lC&lt;;orngenetic resources. and then to build panying document. Agenda 21. actually
upon these "bundles" to achieve omlines funding priorities to implement
Indigenous peoples' goals. Indigenous this process. As a result. considerable
people will lead the process or develop- global funding will be directed toward
ing this framework according to their the exploitation of Indigenous knowlspecific needs and pr11ctices.
edge and biogenetic r~sources.
b) BiOl&gt;rospec ting: Second. an
Biodiversity Prospecting and
increasingly large number or companies
Economic Activities
are ..biodiversily prospecting--that is,
To understand wh)' the safeguarding looking for biogenetic resources (plants,
of knowledge has recently become a ~mimals, bactcritt, etc.), including
major issue for Indigenous peoples. con- human genes. that can be used in the
sider the following pointS:
biotechnology industry. Quinine and
9

�PERSPECTIVES ON BIODIVERSITY AND INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY

curare are familiar examples or this phe-

nomcnOI'l, Never before. however. have
there been so many companies and collecting organizations interested in those
biogenetic resources that have been nur-

tured. protected and even improved by
Indigenous peoples. The Guajajara peo.
pie or Brazil use a plant called
Pl1il0&lt;atpus jaJxmmdi to tr~at glaucoma.
Although Brazil now cams $25 million a
)1
ear from exporting the plant. the
Guajajara have suffered from debt peon·
age and slavery at the hands of agents or
the companr hwolved in the trJ.de.
Funhcrmore. Pilocarpus populations
have nearly been ,,;ped out by ravenous. unsustainable collecting pracciccs.
c) Economic possibilities for
Indigenous peoples: Lastly. many
Indigenous communhics need and are
looking for economic altemati\'tS. In the
tropics. there arc oflen few economic
options other than timber exu-action,
mining, and ranching. Yet. the tropical
ecosystems are constantly touted as
being one or the richest in biodiversity.
\Vith a huge potentiaJ for cJiscoverie.s Of
new medicines. foods. dyes. fertilizers.
essences. oils, and molecules of prime
biotechnological use. ln summary, the
problem or knowledge and genetic
resource exploitation nov.• experienced
by Indigenous communities is only the
stan or a huge aV'31anche.

The Right to Say " NO," and
Categories of Protection
The first concern stated b&gt;'
Indigenous peoples in every imemation·
al forum is their right not to sell. commoditize, or have expropriated cenain
domains of knowledge :md ccrtai!'l
sacred places. plants. animals. and
objects. Subsequent decisions 10 sell.
commoditize. or privmize are only pos-sible if this bas•c right c;~.n be exercised.
At least nine categories o£ traditional
resourccsllndigenous intellectual prop·
Crt)' can be identifkd which a people or
community may be concerned to pro·
teet £rom mi.S&lt;1pproprianon: l. Sacred
properly (images. sounds. knowledge.
10

material culture. or anything that is
deemed sacred}. 2. Knowledge or currem usc. previous usc. potential use of
plam and animal species. as well as soils
and minerals, kno\Vn to the ctthural
group; 3. Knowledge of preparation,
processing. storage or useful species; 4.
Knowledge of formulations involving
more than one ingredient: 5. Knowledge
or individual species (planting methods.
caring for. selection criteria. etc.}: 6.
Knowledge of ecosystem conservation
(that protects commercial value.
although not specifically used for that
purpose or other practical purposes by
the local community or the culture); 7.
Biogenetic rcsour&lt;:es that originate (or
originated) on indigenous lands and ter~
ritories~ 8. Cultural heritage (images.
sounds. crafts. ans. perfonnances}; 9.
Classificatory syStems of knowledge.
Quite clearly. knowledge is a thread
common to all t hesc categories. Many
Indigenous groups have e.xpressed their
desire that all or these be protected as
pan of the larger need to protect land.
territory. resources and to stimulate self·
determination. Control over culu.lr:\1,
scientific and irndlectual property is de
facto self-determination-although only
after rights to land and terriwry are
secured by law and practice (i.e..
boundaries are recognized. protected.
and guaranteed by law}. But. as many
Indigenous peoples have discovered.
even guaranteed demarcation of land
and territory does not necessarily mean
free access 10 the resources on that land
or territory. nor the right to exercise
their o v.rn cultures or even lO be com·
pensated for the biogenetic resources
that they have kept. conserved. managed. and molded for thous.1nds of

&gt;
'cars.

The Search for an Alternative
Framework: Starting points for
a new system
A wide range of imcmational agree·
tnems, dedarations. and draft docu·
ments have relevance £or building a
newly designed S)'SLem to protect

Traditional Resourc'C Rights. These are
labor law: human rights laws and agreements: econo1nic and social agreements:
intcllccmll propel'ty and plant variety
protection: fanners' rights; erwironmen·
tal conventions and law; religious free·
dom acts; cultural propeny and cultural
heritage; customaty law, and traditional
practice. Highlights from each or these
areas arc described below.
Labor Law: IPR and ILO
The International labor Organization (ILO) was the first UN organization to deal whh lndiger1ous issues.
establishing a Comn1iuec of Experts on
Native Wbor in 1926 to develop inter·
national standards for the protection or
native workers. In 195 7. the !LO pro·
duced the Com•emion Conccmiug the

PrOle:ction and lntc.:grarion of lndigenou$
and 01ltcr Tribal anti Semi-Tribal
Populmians in Independent Countries
(107). This was rewritten in 1987 as the
Com•ention Cot~cembtg lndigetJ&lt;ncs Peoples
in Independent Cottnlrit.-s (Convention
169} with much or the original~ "inte·
grationist l~nguagc" removed . The con·
vc1nion's key &lt;:omtibutiOrl is lO guaran·
tee Indigenous peoples' rights to deter·
mine and control their own economic,
social and cultural developmcm. It also
recognizes the collective ospcct or
Indigenous possessions. which is of
obvious importance to IPR issues. since
collectivity is fundamental to transmis·
sion. use and protection of traditional
knowledge. Until now, Convention 169
has not been sufficiently used with
implementation of IPR in mind.

liuman Rights a1td lntellc&lt;:t ual
Property
lmcrnational human rights laws offer
some mechanisms for cuhurnl protec~
lion. The princ.•pal problem is thot these
are oriented toward n:uion-statcs and do
not easily "provide a basis for claims
againsl multinational companies or indi·
viduals who profit £rom traditional
knowledge.• The 1948 Unive~·sal
Dedararion of Human Righu 3_ d the
n

Abya Yala News

�PERSPECTIVES ON BIODIVERSITY AND INTELLECTUAl PROPERTY

Hundreds of potato varieties are grown and preserved by Andean peoples

1966 lnccr·natlomzl Ccwenmu on ECOtlOmic.
Indigenous pc:oplts luwc: tht right ro tl1t
Social tmtl Culrur'al Rights guarantee f1.111· t&gt;rotc:ctlon and, wllerl: at'P'Otniatc, the
damemal freedoms of personalintegrily re.ltabilitation of tltc rowl environment and
and action; political rights: social and productive capacily of their lands ruul terti·
economic rights: cuhuml rights and tories. and the rig1H lO tldequatt assisumce
equal protection under the law. Within including irucmalio,lal cooperacicn to this
this gu3rantcc is the right of self-deter- trul.
mination. including the right to dispose
It is dear that IPR should to be seen a.s
of natural wealth and resources. This a basic Iutman riglu, worthy of incorporaalso implies the right to protect and con- tion in tht C&lt;lmpaigns of lwman ,ights org:aserve -resources. including intellectu:.\.1 nit&lt;tlions.
property.
Signincantl)• these human rights
.
Econon'lic and Social Agreements
laws also protect the right to own co11ec·
In 1972. the United Nations
tive propeny. as well as guaranteeing the Economic and Social Council fonned a
right to just and favorable remuneration special human rights Sub·Commission
for work-which can be interpreted ns to Study the problem of discrimination
work related 10 traditional knowledge. against Indigenous peoples. After releas·
Finali)'. they provide for "recognition of ing a lengthy repon that found inadeinterest in scientific production. includ· quate protection of Indigenous peoples'
ing the right to the protection of the rights whhin existing international
moral and material interests resulting insrrumems. the Sub-Commission
(rOO'l any scientific literary or anisliC released various resolutions recomproduction.·
mending U&gt;althe UN "Provide explicitly
This language is echoed in the Draft for the role of Indigenous peoples as
Dcdm·ation on tlte Rights of Indigenous resource users and managers, and ror
Peoplc~s which states:
the protection of Indigenous peoples'
Vol. s No.4

right to comrol of their o'vn tmditional

knowledge of ecosystems." It also
requested the Secretary-General to prepare a concise report on the c.xtcm to
which existing imernational standards
and me&lt;:h:misms serve Indigenous people in the protection of Lheir intellectual
property. The human righlS commission has played an important role in

pressuring other UN agencies to take
action through these calls for protection
of. and protection for. Indigenous peoples' IPR.
Folklore and Plant Variety Protection
The U n iu~d Nations Educational.
Scientific and Cultural Organization
(UNESCO) should be a logical forum for
IPR discussion: yet, while UNESCO hns
heard "petitions" of complaints by native
peoples related to the fields of education. sde.nce. culture and inronnation,
Indigenous questions remain marginal
10 UNf:SCOs agenda.
The World lntellccwal Property
Organization (WIPO) in Geneva has
123 member states that have reached
11

�PERSPECTIVES ON B IODIVERSITY AND

IHTELLECTUALc..P ~::;P E RTY _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __
~~ :..cRO :.,::,:::.:.!.....

tions or ~rarmers' rights• and '"breeders! gested that IPR is essentially a question
rights" have been extensively debated in of religious freedom for indigenous peothis context . In 1987 FAO established a ples. ..- uch o£ what they \VC\I'lt tO COO\·
M
fund for pL1m genetic resources. with mercialize is sacred to us. \Ve see imel·
the idea that seed producers would vol- lectual property as pan or our cultureuntarily contribute according to the vol- it eannot be separated into categories as
ume of their seed sales in order to I\Vestcml lawyei'S would wam."' Pauline
r
finance projeCtS for SUStainable USC of ·- angipoa, a Maori leader, agrees:
plant genetic resources in the Third "Indigenous peoples do not li•nit their
~'or1d. Unfortunately, major seed pro·
religions to buildings, but rather see the
du~rs like the USA opposed mandatory s.'cred in all life."
Exploitation and Other Pr&lt;judicial Actions,
which recognized individual and &lt;:ollec· contributions to the fund. and il has
Cultural Property
ti"e folklore tr.1ditions. Though ne"er turned out to be totally inadequate.
ratified. these provisions-backed up by
In re~m )'ears, Indigenous peoples
Etwironmental law: life after the have been incre-asingly successful in
criminal pena1L1cs-proposcd prote(tion
Earth Summit
reclaiming the tangible aspects or their
of folklore. including material which has
not been written down. ·rheir secon.d
The Rio Decl&lt;lralion which emergtd cultures. or •cultural property." from
important contribmion was to provide from the Earth Summit highl.ighted the museums aod institutions. This tenn
for copyright protection or folkloric per- central importance Indigenous peoples has yet to be clearly defined, but has
formances.
have in attaining suStainable develoP" come to refer tO C\'erything from objects
Within W IPO's jurisdiction, the ment. The Summits legally binding of an to archaeological anifacts, trndi·
Union ror the ProtecLion of new V.1rieties "Convention on Biological Diversity"' donal music and dance:. and sacred sites.
of Plants provides protect ion to breeders (CBD) does not explicitly recognize IPR The concept of ·cultural heritage· has
of new plant varieties that are "'clearly for Indigenous peoples. but its language aJ)I&gt;earcd as a related "legal instn.nnem ..
distinguishable," suficiemly homoge- can easily be interpreted to call for such to link knowledge and information to
neous.'" and "'stable in essential charac· protection. Following effective lobbying the cultural anifact, and has been used
lCriSlicS.,.
by Indigenous organizations. signatories successfully as a legal tool in Australia.
The critical factor here is to link folk- to the Convention have pledged to:
lore and plant genetic resources with respect. presen1e and maintain knowl ~ Customary Law and Traditional
intellectual property. his this complicat- edge, innovations. and practices of Practice
During inrormal hearings ror the
ed legal linkage that allows for expan- Indigenous and local communities
sion of the concept of IPR to include tra- embodying traditional lifestyles relevant 1992 Earth Summit in Rio de Janeiro.
ditional knowledge. not only about for the conservalion and sustainable use Indigenous representatives pointed out
species use.. but also about species man· of biological diversity, and to promote several basic problems with the conagcmcnt. Thus. ecosystems that Me their wider applic:uion with the ceptS of intelleCtual and euhural propermolded or modified by a human pres- approval and involvement of the holders ty: I) The di,osions between cuhural,
ence are a product of Indigenous intel- of such knowledge. innovations and intellectual. and ph)rsical propeny are
lectual property as well, and. conse- practices as well as to encourage the. not as distinct and mutually exclusive
quently, are products themselves-or equitable sharing of the benefits arising for Indigenous peoples as in the Westem
offer products-that are protectable. from the use of such knowledge. inno- legal system. 2) Knowledge generally is
Furthermore. "'wild .....semi-domesticat· vations and practices. Agenda 21. which communally held. and. a.lthough some
ed" (or "semi-wild"). and domesticated accompanies the Convention. specifical- specialized knowledge may be held by
plant and animal species are products of ly includes Indigenous peoples and tra- cenain ritual or society specialists (such
human activity and should also be pro- ditional knowledge in its "priorities for as shamans). this does not give the SJ&gt;e·
action"' toward sustainable develop ~ dalists the right to privatize communal
tectable.
heritage. 3) Even if legal IPR regimes
ment.
Fannc·rs· Rights and the FAO
were put in place. most Indigenous
The UN Food and Agriculture Religious Freedom
comnmnities ,.,,ould not have: the finan·
In a seminar on IPR at the United cial means to implemem. enforce. or litOrganization (FAO) has worked to find
ways for developing countries and Nations Human Rights Con\'entiOI'l i1'l igate them. It was clear that under some
..Third \\'orld rarmers'" to get a share in Vienna, June. 1993. Ray Apoaka of the drrnmstances commercialization or
.
the huge global seed market. The ques· Nonh American Indian Congress sug- knowledge and plam genetic resoun.-es
continued on pg. 37

broo1d agreements on the terms .;indus·

trial property'
and · copyright."
Ho\vevcr. wilhin the \Vli&gt;O framework
Indigenous IPR. as cotleclive propeny.
would be considered folklore and not
protcctable.
In 1984. however, UNESCO and
WI f&gt;O developed Model Previsions fer
Natiorwl Laws on the Proccction of
Exi&gt;rcssions cf Foll1lcr&lt; Against Illicit

12

IV&gt;-(a Yala News

�CONT I N U ED

Biodiversity, Community Integrity
and the Second Colonialist Wave

Guatemala Peace
Talks

&lt;
Continued from pg.12)

&lt;Continued from pg.26)

mighr be desirable. bm rhe prime desire
f&lt;&gt;r Indigenous peoples was an IPR
regime that suppons their righl to s.1y
'"NOM to privatization and commercial·
iu
uion.

Indigenous delcgares mcering in Rio
de Janeiro released rhe Kari·O.:a
Dttlamrion and ln&lt;lig&lt;nous Peoples' Earrh
Charter. Clause 95 Slates d&gt;at "Indigenous
wisdom musr be reoognized and cnoour·
aged." but warns in Clause 99 thar
"Usurping of traditional medicines and
knowledge from Indigenous peoples
should be considered a crime against peoples." Clause I 02 of rhe Kari·&lt;Xa

to discuss rhc evolving IPR debate.
During the 1993 UN Year for the
Worlds Indigenous Peoples. intellectual
and cultural property righiS were on the
agenda of ne.1rly every major Indigenous
encounter.
One of the most lacking areas of IPR
research is that or non·western IPR
regimes. Up to now. the debate has centered around UN and \Vestem concepts
of intellectual and genetic property. But
whar abom the property rxgimcs of
Indigenous peoples themselves? A syn·
thesis and :\nalysis of non-Western S)'$tems would be very helpful in finding
cre:uive solutions to IPR protection.

Declaration is e.xplicit about indigenous
peoples' concern on IPR issues:
As creators &amp; carriers of civllizar!ons Conclusion
\\·hich have given &amp; conlirwc ro sJwrt
It is fundamental that IPR/TRR
lmowltdgc, experience &amp; values with should nor be used simp!)• 10 reduce tra·
humanity, we n::quht that our rig'u to intc:l· ditional knowledge into Western legal
·
kcttwl &amp; cultural t&gt;roperties be guarameed and conccprual frameworks: Indigenous
&amp; that the mechanism for racl1 implemrn· legal systems and conccprs of property
ration l&gt;t in favor of our p&lt;oplrs &amp; srudied righiS should guide the debate. The role
in depth &amp; imt'ltmcnU&lt;L This respect must of scicmists, scholars and law)'ers
lndude the right over gttiClit raourtt."S, should be to provide informarion and
gtlle banks. biorechrwlogy &amp; knowledge of ideas; it will be Indigenous and rradibiodivCI"&gt;ily programs.
rional peoples rhemsclves who will. in
Since the Earth Summir. dozens of man&gt;' different ways. define Tradhionll
conferences, seminars and workshops Resource Righrs rhrough practice and
ha,·e been held by Indigenous peoples experimentation.

VOi:SNo. 4

ator to work with both panies.
On January 4. 1995. Siglo Veinliuno
reponed that President Ramiro de Leon
plans to sign a peace agreement on
Februar&gt;' 24. The more direct intervention of rhe UN Secretar)' General
appe~rs to be producing results. but it
remains to be seen.
It is interesting to note that neither
Lhe Government nor the URNG has
clearl&gt;' presented its respective posilion
to the Maya community or to the
Guatemalan populace. Each of the tWO
seem to have used the Maya comnnmily
as a pretext to drag out the process
toward a peace that didn'l sui! either
one. In times of peace. you cannot justif)' the e.xistence of a repressive military.
nor of a radical guerrilla movcmenl.
That is why we must contin\IC to
rcasscn the final words of Se&lt;:rctary
General Ghali : "The participants in the
Guatemalan pe-ace process must. renew
their commiuncut to a dynamic negota·
tion that provides clear direcuon
towards a quick and just resolution lO
the conflict." Along wirh Mr. Ghali. the
Maya. the principal-and numerous-vic·
tims of this conflict, request ..a jltSt resolution" for themselves, for their children
and for Guatemala.
37

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="51">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="27240">
                  <text>Vol. 8, no. 4 (Winter 1994)</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27671">
                <text>Safeguarding Indigenous Knowledge: Intellectual Property Rights and the Search for a New Framework</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="51">
            <name>Type</name>
            <description>The nature or genre of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27672">
                <text>Journal Article</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="39">
            <name>Creator</name>
            <description>An entity primarily responsible for making the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27673">
                <text>Darrell A. Posey</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27674">
                <text>1994</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="44">
            <name>Language</name>
            <description>A language of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27675">
                <text>English</text>
              </elementText>
              <elementText elementTextId="46711">
                <text>English</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
      <elementSet elementSetId="5">
        <name>Zotero</name>
        <description/>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="314">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27676">
                <text>Safeguarding Indigenous Knowledge: Intellectual Property Rights and the Search for a New Framework</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="217">
            <name>Item Type</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27677">
                <text>Journal Article</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="190">
            <name>Author</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27678">
                <text>Darrell A. Posey</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="319">
            <name>Volume</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27679">
                <text>8</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="264">
            <name>Issue</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27680">
                <text>4</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="283">
            <name>Pages</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27681">
                <text>9-12, 37</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="293">
            <name>Publication Title</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27682">
                <text>Abya Yala News: Journal of the South and Meso American Indian Rights Center (SAIIC)</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="221">
            <name>ISSN</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27683">
                <text>1071-3182</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="246">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27684">
                <text>1994</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="269">
            <name>Language</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27685">
                <text>English</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="222">
            <name>Abstract Note</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27686">
                <text>Safeguarding traditional knowledge and biogenetic materials has become a major issue among indigenous peoples. The article explores what is at stake for indigenous communities as well as possible frameworks for protecting resources and knowledge.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="322">
            <name>Attachment Title</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27687">
                <text>Safe_guarding_indigenous_knowledge.pdf</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="323">
            <name>Attachment URL</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27688">
                <text>[No URL]</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="320">
        <name>Bioprospecting</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="296">
        <name>Intellectual Property Rights</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="350">
        <name>Traditional Resource Rights</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="1698" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="684">
        <src>https://www.abyayalanews.org/files/original/1bb2efbe8cd349e7daa403d0bf711eb5.pdf</src>
        <authentication>f352b0e5fe8a6d35655c754210b87d6e</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="6">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="324">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="30018">
                    <text>PERSPECTIVES ON B I ODIVERSITY A ND INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY - - - - - - - - - - - -

The Guaymi Patent
One of the best known cases of attempts to patent and commer·
cialize human tissue is that of a still unidentified Ngobe (or Guaymi)
woman of Panama. In 1993 and 1994. this case captured not only
the attention of the international community of scientists. but also
that of Indigenous people world-wide.

by Atenciolopez M
.

I

n 1991 . ~ very ill 26-ye:&gt;r old Ngobc
woman sought medical treatment in
a hospital in ~anama City. Doctors

there diagnosed her with a fatal case of
l. uktmia. This woman could not have
e
lmagined that the Panamanian doctors.
with the complicity of US sciemists,
would then remove s.1mples of her
blood for experimentation and finally

StOre her genetic material in biological
laboratories several thousand miles
away in the US. The doctors who set this
in motion have refused to divulge the
woman$ name. As a resuh we have been
unable to locate her. nor do we know if
she is Still alive. Even if she were alive. it
is doubtful that she would be able to
make sense of the fact that two sup·
posed inventors. Michael Dale Laimore
and jonathan E. Kaplan, nearly acquired
monopoly rights over pan of her body,
or that this action was supported by the
US governments Secretary or Commerce
through its branch that regulates the

patenting of scientific innovations.
These scientists claimed to be search·

ing for dues to understand aborigina.l
peoples in the Americas and to generme

grea.ter understanding of HLV, the \rims
thought to cause AIDS. But their actions
point to different. and significantly more
commercial. iotcmions. In 1993. they
filed a '"high priority" palent claim.
which was given the number
Alcncfo Loptt is a Kuna Indian and wo,.k.s
with the OpXanitation Ktmas Unidos per
Napguana in Panama City.
16

U$612.707. and t itled • Human
Lymphotrophic Virus Type 2 from the

Guayrni Indians of Panama... According
to the application it was based on the
"cell line of a 26·year old Gua)'mi
wom{ln who lives in Panama'".

Irnernarionally. the patent request is reg·
istered with the World lmelleetual
Propeny Organization as number
U$9108455.
Not only this unidentified woman,

but hundreds of Indians in Panama ,..,crt
treated as guinea pigs for genetic e~per­
imemation during this ~me time peri*
od. Kaplan describes the researchers
visit for s.-1mple collections., "'We spent
six days in Canquinlu. Some of the doc~
tors worked in the heahh ctnter a&lt;hnini.stering medicines to the Guayrni pco*
pie. while others worked with nurses
interviewing the residems of the village
and obtaining more blood samples."' The
lndigneous community was never
infonned of the intent or implications or
these collections: the purpose o f the
blood samples was known only tO the
researchers.
One witness affinns 1hm doctors of
the Gorgas 'Memorial Laboratory of
Panama collaborated in this research.
that they used the blood samples of
hundreds of Ngobe I&gt;Cople. and that the
blood samples collected in the process
were subsequently sent to the Center for
Disease Control in Atlanta, Georgia, and
tO the American Type Culture Collection
in Maryland . The ostensible purpose
wns to investigate the cause of a fatal

form or blood cancer. as well as forms of
the Human l.ymphotrophic Virus. but
the patent application followed shonly
thereafler.
This Guaymi case was denounced in
international human rights forums and
before the United Nations, but received
little alttlllion in P~nam.a. due in pan to
a 1:-tck of familiarity with the issues.
Only a small percentage of the main·
stream culture understood what had
taken place. Worst of all. the
Panamanian government sided with the
US scientists and even utilized some
Indigenous organizations itl an auempt
to discredit the protests. Nonetheless.
the Ngobc-Bugle General Congress. the
Kuna General Congress. and other
Panam3nian indigenous organizations
issued strong statements agains1 the
patent application.
Following public protests in the
Geneva meeLings for the GATT in
October of 199~. in Canada and the
United States, as well as widespread
international solidarity. the patent claim
wttS withdrawn in the United Sta.tes-:lt
least that is what we believe. based on a
statement in the NO\'Cmber 5. 1993.
issue or Science magazine. There. in
sharp contradiction 10 earlier humanit:uian claims, Kaplan is quoted as s.1ying
that the daim was being dropped as it
"'has no comrnerci3l interest ."'
These researchers shield themselves
and their actions with the claim that
their work is for the benefit of humani..
t)'. and that they are innocent of any
ir'lcnt to harm the ln(ligenovs communities invoh·ed. Yet. it is undeniable
that the rights of an Indigenous
woman, as well as the rights of an cnlire
community. wert violated. The national
sovereignty of Panama was also violated
in this pl'ocess. although the government comim,u~s to deny this. \Nhat will
happen when the results of th is
research are finall)' patented. or the
rights are sold to a muhinational corpo*
ration? Shall we always continue to be
the objects of research. with no rights
in the mauer?

Abya Yala Ne.NS

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="51">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="27240">
                  <text>Vol. 8, no. 4 (Winter 1994)</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27783">
                <text>The Guaymi Patent</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="51">
            <name>Type</name>
            <description>The nature or genre of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27784">
                <text>Journal Article</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="39">
            <name>Creator</name>
            <description>An entity primarily responsible for making the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27785">
                <text>Atencio Lopez M.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27786">
                <text>Winter 1994</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="44">
            <name>Language</name>
            <description>A language of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27787">
                <text>English</text>
              </elementText>
              <elementText elementTextId="46717">
                <text>English</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
      <elementSet elementSetId="5">
        <name>Zotero</name>
        <description/>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="314">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27788">
                <text>The Guaymi Patent</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="217">
            <name>Item Type</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27789">
                <text>Journal Article</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="190">
            <name>Author</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27790">
                <text>Atencio Lopez M.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="319">
            <name>Volume</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27791">
                <text>8</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="264">
            <name>Issue</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27792">
                <text>4</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="283">
            <name>Pages</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27793">
                <text>16</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="293">
            <name>Publication Title</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27794">
                <text>SAIIC Newsletter</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="221">
            <name>ISSN</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27795">
                <text>1071-3182</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="246">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27796">
                <text>Winter 1994</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="269">
            <name>Language</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27797">
                <text>English</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="222">
            <name>Abstract Note</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27798">
                <text>Between 1993 and 1994, a group of American scientists attempted to patent and commercialize a sample of human tissue collected from an unidentified indigenous woman. Indigenous groups and international human rights forums denounced the effort and the scientists subsequently withdrew their patent claim.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="322">
            <name>Attachment Title</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27799">
                <text>The_guaymi_patent.pdf</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="323">
            <name>Attachment URL</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27800">
                <text>[No URL]</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="181">
        <name>Guaymi</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="20">
        <name>Human Rights</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="296">
        <name>Intellectual Property Rights</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="182">
        <name>Ngobe</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="301">
        <name>Patent Law</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="1671" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="710">
        <src>https://www.abyayalanews.org/files/original/0cbf9c0e9e62055028489b82ced8e624.pdf</src>
        <authentication>2f994b26b83ffa990d5154782a93a883</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="6">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="324">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="30044">
                    <text>PERSPECTIVES ON B IODIVERSITY AND INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY

The Human Genome
Diversity Project:
Implications for Indigenous Peoples
We reported on the Human Genome Diversity Project in Abya Yala 's Dec. 1994 issue. Indigenous
opposition to the project has been growing since that time. and the project has yet to respond ade·
quately to fundamental ethical problems such as those raised in this article.

By Debra Harry
he HUinan Genome Diversity
Project (HGD Project) proposes
to collect blood and 1issue so1m ·
pies from hundreds of different
Indigenous groups worldwide for

T

gcnc1ic swdy.

On the assumption 1hat

these groups are headed for extinction,
sc-ientists :ue rushing to gather DNA
somples before they disoppe•r. Then,

Issues of Concern
HGO Project sciemists claim to be
searching ror answers to questions about
human evolution. However, Indigenous
peoples already possess strong beliefs
and knowledge regarding their creation
and hiStories: funhemlore. this is not a
ptiotity concern for Indigenous people.
The HGD Projects assumptions that the

they say. ;u least the human genetic
diversity will be prcser:vcd in gene
banks as "'immortalized cell lines." BUl
why the tremendous interest in sa\ring
the genes of Indigenous people •nd not
the people themselves? Who rc311y

populations will be "discovered" and
sdemilkally •answered" is insuhing to
groups who already ha\'Cstrong cuhural
beliefs regording their origins. What
will be the ilnpact or a scientific theory

stands to benefit from this endeavor?

of evolution and migration that is ami·

What •rc the dangers and long-term
implications of biotechnology and
genetic engineering? These are ques·
tions Indigenous people must ask them·
selves tn order w protect their interests
in lite face or such a mysterious and
well-funded cffon.

thetical to an ln&lt;ligenous groups com·
mon beliefs? Will these new theories be
used to challenge aboriginal territorial
cl•ims, or rights to l•nd?

Debra Harry is a Paitde Indian from Ntmda,
USA. Sl1e is n:scarchirtg ISS!(f.S rdatrd lo IPR
•nd the HGD Proj&lt;Cl.
Vol.8 No. 4

origins and/or migrations of Indigenous

Medical Benefits?
The often repeated claim that med·
ical applications will be developed to
tre•t diseases sulfered by Indigenous
peoples is a complete misrepresemation
of the Project. •nd scn•es to coerce the

participation of subj~ts based on the
false hope for medical n&gt;ir:~cles. The
Project's mandate is simply to collect.
database. and maintain genetic samples
Md dma, not to develop medic•! appli·
C.3tions.
The HGD Project will make the
genelic samples available to "the pub·
lie ... However, it is not clear who will
have access to the data and actual
genetic samples. It appears that the
HGD Project will maintain an open·
access policy. This me&lt;~ns th3t once
genetic ma1erials are stored in gene
banks. they will be available in perpe·
tuity. with minimal control. to anyone
requesting access. Scientists need only
demonstr:\te the validity of thei r scien·
tific research in order to gain access to
the samples. Medical applications are
in fact likely 10 result from the eventual research. manipulation. and commercialization or the genetic materials.

But they will mosl likely come in the

form of pharmaceuticals or expensive
genetic therapy techniques. Possible
benefits ";II go only to those who can
13

�PERSPECTIVES ON BIODIVERSITY AND INTELLECTUAl PROPERTY

afford the high costs of such treat ·
ments.

The proposition that medical bene·
fits will result from genetic &amp;'tmpling is
further suspect since no aspect of the
project will take imo account the role
that existing and historical socio-eco·
nomic or environmental conditions

play in the health of lndigcnoll5 com·
munitics.

lf an Indigenous popuhuion were
interested in researching a genetic ques·
tion spec,ific to their group. they would

not need the HGD Project to do so.
Genetic research te&lt;:hnology and cxper·

Since 1980: .. there has been a
disturbing trend in US patent
law that extends patent protec·
tion to life forms.
tise is widely available. The enticement
of potential medical benefits is an empty
promise which will be used to gain
access to communities for the collection
of samples.

Commercialization. Ownership
and Intellectual Property Rights
The HGD Project l'l!iscs inevitable
questions regarding both ownership of

the genetic samples themselves and who
stands to profit from the commcrcializa..

tion of products derived from the sam~
pies. The Proje&lt;:t puts Indigenous peoples' most fundamental property-their
own genes-in the hands of anyone who
wants to experiment with them. In
dotng so. the Project opens the door to
widespread commcrci31ization and
potential misuse of the samples and
data.
The Project will enable "bioprospectors" to stake legal claims on the natural
genetic resource base of Indigenous pe:o·
14

pies. Some of those claims will strike it
rich, in the fom&gt; of profitable patents. As
in the case of future medical applications. the d irect benefits from the HGD
gene banks will go to those who can
arTord 10 invest in research , manipulation and commercialization of the genetic data. Patent law will be the primary
vehicle which enables scientists to
secure exclusive rights to the genetic
samples. Patent laws gl'llnt a limited
propcrt)' right to the patent holder and
exclude others from using the patented
item for a specific period of time. usually for n 17 -yeaq&gt;eriod.

Patenting Human Genes
Since 1980. when the US Supreme
Coun ruled that the creation of an oil·
t..1.ting microbe ls patemable. there has
been a disturbing trend in US patent law
that extends patent protection to life
forms. Since then, the US Patent and
Trademork Office ( PTO) has granted
patents for newly created micro-organ ..
isms, living animals. and for human tiS·
sues and genes, b reaking the longstanding policy thm animate life forms
were not patentable. The National
Institutes of Health. and others. ha,,e
secured patent rights for fl'llgmcnted
gene sequences. many with unknown
function and physical significance. This
lrend has enabled research inslitutions
and corporations to secure patents for
almost 5% of the entire human genome,
and has spurred a ntsh for o'vnership of
the remaining 95% of the human
genome.
Does anyone have the right to own a
life form or to commodify parts of the
human body&gt; While many debate the
ethical and mol'lll implia.tions or patenting life fonns, in 1993 US Secretary of
Commerce Ron Bro"" filed a patent
claim on the cell line of a 26-year-&lt;&gt;ld
Guayami woman from Panarna. Her ceH

line was of interest because some
Guaya.mi people carry a unique \~rus,
and their antibodies may prove useful in
AIDS
and
leukemia
research.
Fortunately, intetnational protest and
action by the Guaymi General Congress
and others led to the withdrawal of the
patent claim by the US Secretary of
Commerce in November 1993.
Patent claims have also been filed by
the Secretary of Commerce for the cell
lines of Indigenous people from the
Solomon Islands. The Solomon Islands
Government has demanded withdrawal
of the patent applications and repatriation of the genetic samples. citing ar1
invasiort of sovereignty, lack of
informed consent. and moral grounds
as the reasons for protest. In early
March. Secretary Ron Bro\llfl rejected
these requests. stating that .. there is no
provision for considel'lltions related to
the source of the cells that ma)' be the
subject of a patent application." In
other words, according to existing
patent lav..•, the source of a genetic sam·
pie is irrelevant.
Indigenous people must be aware
that it may be extremely difficult or
impossible to recover or reparriate sam·
pies of our blood, tissues. or body pans,
once lhty arc remo·ved from our bodies
and stored elsewhere. In 1984 john
Moore filed a lawsuit claiming that his
blood cells were misappropriated while
he was undergoing trearmem for
leuken'tia at the University of Califomia.
los Angeles Medical Center. During his
trealmem. Moore~ doctor developed a
cell line which proved '"'luable in fighting bacteria and cancer. The UCLA
Board of Regents r.led a patent claim on
this cell line from which they developed
commercially valuable antibacterial and
cancer-fighting ph3rmaceuticals. Moore
claimed that he ' v:IS emltled to share in
pror.ts derived from commercial uses of
Abya Ya.a News
l

�PERSPECTIVES ON B IODI VERSITY AND I NTELLECTUAL PROPERTY

these cells ~nd any other products
resulting from reseateh on any of his
biological materials. In a significant
l990 California Supreme Coun deci·
sion. the court established that '"donors·
do not have an IPR property right in the
tissues removed from their body (6).

genes.

Sample Collection

seems like sc.ience fiction to many peo-

The HGD Project will seek the conscm of the individuals and populations
to be sampled. Questions of what con-

ple. it is a reality. Through genetic engineering, scientists are capable of reprogramming the genetic codes of living

stiuncs '"infomled consem" ~md how it
will be secured remain to be answered.
The HGD Project has secured a gram

things to meet societtd or economic
goals. Transgenic experiments can rni.x
pJam genome with that of animals. and
human genome with that of plams or
animals. The ethical and legal questions

prillls· cf living organisms. C- rle technofo·
c
gy ma,~cs it possible tc isofatt, s-plfct. insert,
rearrar1ge, r-ecombiru: aJUI

mass-r·ep!Q{II~Cc

placemal tissues as sources for genetic
samples? How will the project be
explained in the local language? Will the
full scope of the project and the short·

Vol. 8 No.4

about the full scope or this project and

the potcmial dangers of genedc manipulation before they decide whether to
participate. It is impermive that our
communities become fully aware of the
Projects implications and begin documenting proposed or current sample

According to existing patent
law. the source of a genetic
sample is irrelevant.
collecting. 'Vlc need to form an interna..

Nonetheless, this area remains vinually

tiona! Indigenous research group to

unregulated.

determine the e.xtent of existing interna·
tional protec,tions for human materials.

While the HGD Project

itself does not plan to do genetic engineering. no safeguards exist t.o prevent
others from doing so with the HGD
genetic s.1mples.
Genetic manipulation mises serious
ethical and moral concems for
Indigenous peoples. for whom any vi&lt;r
lation or the natural order of life is
abhorrently wrong. Scientists are genet·
ically manipulating existing life fonns.

altering dte course of natural evolution,
and creating new life forms. Genes are
living organisms which reproduce.
migmte and mutate. The full implications or genetically altered life forms

released imo the envirol'tmem cannot
possibly be anticipated.

tlal uses or the samples be fully dis- Recommendations
Indigenous organizations need to
closed? \\r,ll donors be fully informed of
the potential for pro£hs that may be alert all Indigenous peoples to the work
made from their genetic samples?
of the Human Genome Organiz.atfon
(the body governing the HGDP) in order

\Vith ger~t: lic engineer-ing ca.lmology
today. it is P"Ssiblc to manlpulatt the 'bh•e·

genetic materials that

raised by genetic engineering technolo-

gy are nurncrous and unanswered.

a.nd long·term implications and poten·

Other Potential for Misuse

Ml)'

community education ax'ld discussiOt\

-Andrew Kimbrell, The Human
8ody Shop. 1994.
Though genetic engineering still

from the J.D. ~nd C .T. MacArthur
Foundation (despite the expressed
opposition of Native leaders) in order to
develop a model protocol for the collection of genetic samples from lndigenous
groups.
The concept of "informed consem·
rniscs m3ny unanswered questions in
the minds of Indigenous peoples, such
as: Who is authorized to give consent?
Should consent be required only by the
individual being sampled, or also
include the governing body of that par·
ticular tndigenous nation? C.."\n consent
be granted by government o!ftcials or
the nation-state in which Lhe Indigenous
nation is located? How will permission
be obtained for collection o£ samples
from the deod, or for use or fetal and

reclaiming

have already been taken.
Indigenous people must engage in

and to develop additional policies which

insure the protection of our imellecLUal.
cultural and biological propeny rights.
Indigenous people must call for a
world-wide mor3torium on the collec·
tion, datab:~sing. transformation. and
commercialization of cell lines and

genetic materials of Indigenous peoples

umil international standards and regulation are put into place which fully pro·

teet the environment and the interests of
Indigenous peoples.
For Mort lnf()rmation Omrace
Debra Harry, P. 0 . Box 72, Nixon, Nt:\'ada
89~24. 002) 574·0309 tmail:
/)(bra_Narl)•@Togc:ther.org or
dharry@igCAJX:.OI);

jcanncut Atmstrc&gt;ng. En'ow- in Ctnue, 257
k
8fi.UI.SWici.: Sttetl. Pt:nlteton. BC V2A l

n

materials by this project, or by free-lance

(604) 493-7181
RAFl·Canada. (Rural Ad\'at~Ccmtm
Fowtdation tncemalfonal), Suite 504-7 J Bank
Sl'""· Oua..·a. Onwrio KIP 5N2. (613) 567·

scientists. and to assist groups in

6880

lO

pre,·ent the taking of their genetic

15

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="51">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="27240">
                  <text>Vol. 8, no. 4 (Winter 1994)</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27279">
                <text>The Human Genome Diversity Project: Implications for Indigenous Peoples</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="51">
            <name>Type</name>
            <description>The nature or genre of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27280">
                <text>Journal Article</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="39">
            <name>Creator</name>
            <description>An entity primarily responsible for making the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27281">
                <text>Debra Harry</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27282">
                <text>1994</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="44">
            <name>Language</name>
            <description>A language of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27283">
                <text>English</text>
              </elementText>
              <elementText elementTextId="46690">
                <text>English</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
      <elementSet elementSetId="5">
        <name>Zotero</name>
        <description/>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="314">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27284">
                <text>The Human Genome Diversity Project: Implications for Indigenous Peoples</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="217">
            <name>Item Type</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27285">
                <text>Journal Article</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="190">
            <name>Author</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27286">
                <text>Debra Harry</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="319">
            <name>Volume</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27287">
                <text>8</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="264">
            <name>Issue</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27288">
                <text>4</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="283">
            <name>Pages</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27289">
                <text>13-15</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="293">
            <name>Publication Title</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27290">
                <text>Abya Yala News: Journal of the South and Meso American Indian Rights Center (SAIIC)</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="221">
            <name>ISSN</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27291">
                <text>1071-3182</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="246">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27292">
                <text>1994</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="269">
            <name>Language</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27293">
                <text>English</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="222">
            <name>Abstract Note</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27294">
                <text>The Human Genome Diversity Project seeks to collect genetic information from indigenous peoples across the globe.  Indigenous communities should be hesitant to comply, given the potential for misuse and exploitation.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="322">
            <name>Attachment Title</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27295">
                <text>The_human_genome_diversity_project.pdf</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="323">
            <name>Attachment URL</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27296">
                <text>[No URL]</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="302">
        <name>Genetics</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="65">
        <name>Human Genome Diversity Project</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="296">
        <name>Intellectual Property Rights</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="301">
        <name>Patent Law</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="1669" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="712">
        <src>https://www.abyayalanews.org/files/original/da151cfe8a29ff844619be1d34b810a6.pdf</src>
        <authentication>6f891760a8710e8f4ec06d943c5cafbd</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="6">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="324">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="30046">
                    <text>ORGANIZATION

AND

Expanding Indigenous
Journalism in· Central America
ndigenous leaders met in E1 S.1h'11dor
from NO\'. 11 -13 for the second
Centro! Amencan plnnnmg meeting for
the lntcrn:lllon:ll Indigenous Decade.
According 10 the I PS news service, represcntnuves focused on plans to boost
lnd1an news mcdlo 1n the region.
N1cnmguan l ndl~enous leader Mirna
Cunnlngh.'\n po1
nted 10 • pilot project
bemg camw OUI In N1camgua with
md1o and the p~ wh1ch could be ben&lt;flctnl for 1he d.-·elopment of
lnd1genous med1a m Ccntml Amenca.
She ln(ormrd IPS th.'ll the tr;umng of
lndtgenous )oumahsts and professionals
·IS alread)' happemng m the regton.
ah hough 01 modest levels." and added
that the upgmdmg o( CXIStiOg programs
is bcmg sought.
;\dnnn Esquino L1sco. head of the
N•uonal Indigenous Association, stated
that they were thinking of stnrtlng an
lnd1
gcnous mdio station, although they
lacked lnfomtatlon on the current situa·
tlon R1goberta Menchu. who W:J.S also
pr&lt;S&lt;nt at the m&lt;eung, pledgtd the suppon of the Vicente Mcnchu Foundation
m undcnnkmg a study of the oaual situotoon and needs of lnd1genous communmos In Guatemala, Hondur3S.
N1caroguo Jnd the southern Mexican
state of Ch1&gt;p.1S.

COMMUNICATION

of trust "'sponslbiliues h tstoblished a

Zunl on 1ssucs conct'ming n:uu~l

resources. S1gnifl(llmly. the pbn uses
Zuni religto\IS ond cuhuml valuos :J.S the
b:J.Sis for decision-moktng.
This approach to development has
pro\•isions to provide Imming of Zunis already brought a 8"'"t deal of success
to fall profes.~ional positions. the build- to the project and to Zuni. The project
ing of gcogmph1c lnformauon systems. now cmploys60 lll:oplc. 59 of which are
ond elabomtlon of n resource develop- Zuni. lmplernc.nuuion o( lhe pktn 1$ 1n
its first yblr and watershed rehabilitament pion.
Intellectual Property R~ghts is one of lion has already begun. Tmd1tional agothe pLOJ«ts prmctpal concerns. 2um are culture IS molong a comeback and trndl·
in the process of deflmng for themselves uon&gt;l technolog)' lor ci'0$1on control IS
what Zum tmellectu&gt;l proptny IS and being tncorpomt&lt;d mto the rthabohta·
what t)'pt of "pLOt&lt;ctton" they would non \\rork. lnd1gcnous communuzes
hkr to sec for thts proptrt)CTrodutoml tntemauon.tlly have shown amerest in
seeds, for exnmple. need to be plotect· the ptOJCClS appro.1Ch to communuyed. but cnnnot be used-¢,-en by b:J.Sed development
ZunlS-for commerdol purposes. $.1cred
sues. religtous ani(:~cts. trodiuonal an Tribal Sovereignty: Back to the
styles. l:mgungc. religtous ceremonies. Future?
songs. and medicimd plants nre other
his symposiUm on the rights ond
status of Indigenous people was
types Of "property" COnSidered for pro·
tection .
sponsored by 1he St. Thomas University.
A related yet sepamte Issue is that its Hun10n Rights Institute, its law
of cultural preservntlon. Many of school. and the Oklahoma Cuy
Zunt5. tradhaons have endured the pas• Umverslty Notlve Amerlcon Legal
500 years. Zum contmue to pracuce Rcsoun:e Center. It took place m ~hami,
rchgoous and cultuml tmdiuons that Flonda on Dec I and 2 The conference.
ongmatcd thous.mds of years &gt;go. The addressed issues or lod1311 culture and
past 50 yc.• rs. howe\'tr. have brought sptritu&gt;hty "" well M cbiOIS of tnlxtl
about ropld chongcs In dcmograph1cs 50\'treignt)' and cnucal IS&gt;Ues of fcdcral
and hfestylt. The Conserv:mon project lndL1n law. ond was designed 10 Crt.lte a
holds that much of I he do mage 10 Zuni launchmg pad for ongoing research and
lands "'suhcd from the breaking of ana.lysos.
Zuni Conservation Project
traduional forms of land manngcmcnt.
The conference fcaturcd • broad
Pushes Sustainable
and know~ that traditional methods array of subject m~ner ond expen
Development
are much more sustnlnnble, and strh·es speakers from Bmzll to Alnskn. Papers
he Zuni Tnbe loc~ned in wesHcn- 10 mcorpomtc and rtjuvenme the use from the conference and highlights of
tml New Mexico fomted the Zuni of traditional technologies and prac- the discussions will be published in a
Conscrvntlon Pl\)jcct in 199 1 to serve as lices into nnturnl resource use plan· special Spring 1995 issue of the Sr.
th~ir dcl):'rCmem of n:uurnl resources. ning.
Thomas l.aw Re••fcw.
The Zuni communuy has approximately
By the end of 1993. the Zuni
9,000 pe-ople. In 1990, p.15Sag&lt; of the Conse"•auon Pro.JC(t completed a plan For mot&lt; lnformattoto:
the Zuni Conservauon Act enabled of acuon fe&gt;&lt; sustaonablc development Pnlf"'-"'' Slrtfru:d ll'f&lt;»tt&lt;r. Clwlr. Sutnng
l&gt;unchlng of 1hc project The Act was -the Zuno ~rce o.:,·elopment Plan. Commlll« Tribal Sowr&lt;~g~~ly S)Oijli&gt;Wm.
J&gt;35$d to cnd Ol.'lny &gt;~rs of litiW~tion This pbn follows the forn~11 of the UN'S S&lt;. ThDrnM UnM"'IJI S&lt;looal cf l.a"'
&gt;g&gt;lnst the US Go\'cmment for damage Ag.onda 21 doeumem. tn se1ung gu1dc- 16-ICO N IV J2nd "'~ Mwmt, fl&lt;&gt;nd&lt;J JJOSi.
to Zum l•ncb ond f10m mismanag.omem hnes. goals. and .lCioon obJCcti\'CS for Td; (lOS) 62J.2JOS, FGX. (lOS) 62J-2.J90

I

T

16

Sl7 moUton trust fund to set up a system

of bnd management to rehobilit;ue nnd
conserve Zums land and natu.ml
resources. Also Included In the Act ore

T

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="51">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="27240">
                  <text>Vol. 8, no. 4 (Winter 1994)</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27243">
                <text>Zuni Conservation Project Pushes Sustainable</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="51">
            <name>Type</name>
            <description>The nature or genre of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27244">
                <text>Journal Article</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27245">
                <text>Winter 1994</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="44">
            <name>Language</name>
            <description>A language of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27246">
                <text>English</text>
              </elementText>
              <elementText elementTextId="46688">
                <text>English</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
      <elementSet elementSetId="5">
        <name>Zotero</name>
        <description/>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="314">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27247">
                <text>Zuni Conservation Project Pushes Sustainable</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="217">
            <name>Item Type</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27248">
                <text>Journal Article</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="319">
            <name>Volume</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27249">
                <text>8</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="264">
            <name>Issue</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27250">
                <text>4</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="283">
            <name>Pages</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27251">
                <text>36</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="293">
            <name>Publication Title</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27252">
                <text>Abya Yala News: Journal of the South and Meso American Indian Rights Center (SAIIC)</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="221">
            <name>ISSN</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27253">
                <text>1071-3182</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="246">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27254">
                <text>Winter 1994</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="269">
            <name>Language</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27255">
                <text>English</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="222">
            <name>Abstract Note</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27256">
                <text>An indigenous tribe in New Mexico is implementing a sustainable development plan that draws from the tribe's traditional forms of land management.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="322">
            <name>Attachment Title</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27257">
                <text>Zuni_conservation_project.pdf</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="323">
            <name>Attachment URL</name>
            <description/>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="27258">
                <text>[No URL]</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="357">
        <name>Agriculture</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="296">
        <name>Intellectual Property Rights</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="358">
        <name>sustainability</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="612">
        <name>Zuni Conservation Act</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
</itemContainer>
